Facebook Pixel
Gamification Nation Podcast

Podcast 44: Is gaming bad for my child?

Gamification Nation Podcast
Gamification Nation Podcast
Welcome to today's Question of Gamification, the podcast by An Coppens. And today we have a guest, Andy Robertson, who also goes by the Twitter handle @GeekDadGamer, and he's a video game journalist and the author of the book Taming Gaming.

I'm delighted to have Andy with us today because we're going to address the question of: is gaming safe for my child? And it's a funny story how we actually met and how it came about, with me tweeting and re-tweeting some information that I sent out around #GetSetGo, a campaign by UKIE, who is the organization supporting the games and digital entertainments industry.  I was basically quoting that, "Is gaming safe for my child?" Is probably the most frequently asked question I receive at the end of seminars or webinars when I speak about gamification because my audience tends to be adults.

Andy, welcome to the podcast.

Andy Robertson :

Hello. Thanks for having me.

An Coppens :

Yes, delighted to have you. So, let's delve straight in. Is gaming safe for children these days?

Andy Robertson :

Yeah, it's a hot topic, isn't it? And particularly during this period where the amount of games that children are playing is on the increase, and the amount of screen use. And so, often that comes with a bit of baggage, and so usually I'll start to try and unpick it. There are various places we could start.
Gaming classed as a disorder
An Coppens:

Yes, exactly. And I suppose the one place that triggered the conversation for a lot of parents in my view is when the World Health Organization classed gaming as a disorder, and definitely, that's when I saw the increase of questions in this regard, "What should I be watching out for? Is my kid going to be addicted? Should I stop them?" So, do you see that the same way as the World Health Organization? What's your take on that?

Andy Robertson :

I think it is a complex topic. And I'm not against having a gaming disorder clarified so we can talk about it. But I think the challenge is that some of how it's reported was just like, "Now, finally, kids who game too much can get a diagnosis from a doctor and can be sent to clinics and can be fixed, and can be labelled", rather than actually looking at an individual child and thinking, "Okay, what's working for them and what isn't?"

I think the downside was that the danger is that it granted permission to us as parents sometimes to just label an issue that a child might have had, rather than actually taking a step forwards into the games they play and asking them questions, and spending time with them playing to understand what it was and why they were playing.

But that said, if you look at the detail of that gaming disorder criteria that the World Health Organization has specified, I don't really know anyone with a child who would fall into that. We'll often say at the school gate, "My son's addicted to Fortnite", but we don't really mean addiction as the World Health Organization means it, because they talk about if a child is playing games so much it's detrimental to other parts of their life, so they wouldn't be going to school, they wouldn't be eating properly, they probably would be washing properly or taking part in family activities.

And not only that, but once they noticed that and had been told about that, they would then carry on doing it, they would be unable to stop in spite of those negative consequences, and then that would continue for around about 12 months, and then only then do you start falling into this clinical criteria.

So, it's a really extreme end of the spectrum, which I think is actually quite helpful to help us reserve that language of addiction to clinically addicted children, which is in the minority, rather than a label we can apply widely.
Gaming as a passing fad
An Coppens:

I think it's a great explanation, some children, and myself included as a child, I used to love playing a specific game, and I would play it until I fell asleep.
Gamification Nation Podcast
Not playing